TL;DR
Quick Answer
For most insurance-based solo therapists and group practices — the majority of private practice in 2026 — TherapyNotes is the better-value default. It is the stronger insurance biller, it costs less per clinician, it supports e-prescribing for psychiatric prescribers, and its US phone support is the best in the category. Pick SimplePractice instead if you run a cash-pay or hybrid practice where client experience and marketing matter more than billing depth: its client portal, telehealth, mobile app, and built-in Monarch directory are the slickest in behavioral health, and its AI and integration ecosystem is far wider. Pick neither if you want an AI-native, all-in-one platform at a lower monthly cost — look at Upheal or Blueprint, covered in our mental health AI tools guide. The two overlap on the fundamentals — scheduling, notes, telehealth, a client portal, built-in PHQ-9/GAD-7 — so the decision comes down to which problem is actually costing you money: getting paid by insurance (TherapyNotes) or filling and delighting a caseload (SimplePractice).
At a glance
| Feature | SimplePractice | TherapyNotes |
|---|---|---|
| Core identity | Polished all-in-one EHR built on client experience | Workhorse EHR built on insurance billing |
| Starting price | ~$49/mo (Starter), per clinician | ~$59/mo solo; ~$30/mo per added clinician |
| Pricing transparency | Published tiers | Published, usage add-ons |
| Insurance billing | Included; improving but less deep | Best-in-class — batch claims, ERA, clearinghouse |
| Built-in telehealth | Yes, polished | Yes, included |
| Client portal & online booking | Best-in-class | Functional, less slick |
| Mobile app | Strong iOS/Android | Weaker / limited |
| AI notes | AI Note Taker add-on (~$35/mo): SOAP, DAP, BIRP | TherapyFuel add-on (~$40/mo): SOAP only |
| E-prescribing (EPCS) | No native e-prescribe | Yes — key for prescribers |
| Marketing directory | Monarch directory included | None |
| Third-party AI scribe support | Mentalyc, Blueprint, Upheal, Supanote, Twofold | Mentalyc, Blueprint, JotPsych, others |
| Customer support | Email/chat, limited phone | US phone support, highly rated |
| Best for | Cash-pay/hybrid practices prioritizing UX + marketing | Insurance-based, group, and psychiatric practices |
On the numbers below
Behavioral-health software pricing changes often, and the figures on this page were last checked against vendor materials in May 2026 — more than 90 days ago. Treat every dollar amount as "starting around" and confirm the current number on each vendor's own pricing page before you sign. TherapyNotes in particular prices some things (reminders, e-prescribing) as usage-based or per-seat add-ons that don't show up in a headline rate.
What each tool does
SimplePractice and TherapyNotes land on nearly every therapist's shortlist because they solve the same core problem — running an outpatient behavioral health practice end to end — but they were built from opposite ends of the job.
SimplePractice is built around the client experience and the owner's time. Its center of gravity is a genuinely excellent client portal: prospective clients book online, complete intake paperwork and consents on their phone, store a card on file, join telehealth with one tap, and message you securely — all in an interface that looks like a modern consumer app rather than medical software. On top of that sits clean scheduling, customizable documentation, an AI Note Taker add-on, a large integration marketplace, and the Monarch directory, SimplePractice's own "find a therapist" listing that feeds new clients into your practice. The pitch is: look professional, reduce front-desk friction, and keep your caseload full. That's why it dominates the solo and small-group segment — roughly 60%+ of small practices already run on it — and why it shows up across adjacent wellness verticals like our physical therapy practice guide and massage therapy practice guide.
TherapyNotes is built around getting paid. Its center of gravity is insurance billing: a built-in clearinghouse, electronic claim submission (837), electronic remittance posting (ERA/835), batch claims, a built-in to-do workflow that nags you through the revenue cycle, and structured, audit-ready note templates designed so payers don't deny them. It adds scheduling, included telehealth, a client portal, appointment reminders, and — crucially for psychiatric practices — e-prescribing with EPCS for controlled substances, which SimplePractice does not offer natively. The interface is utilitarian, the mobile app is thin, and there's no marketing directory. But for a practice whose revenue lives and dies on clean claims and fast reimbursement, that focus is the whole point.
Both are mature, widely deployed, HIPAA-aware platforms used by tens of thousands of clinicians. Neither is a toy and neither is obscure. The choice is almost never "which is better software" in the abstract. It's "which problem is bleeding money right now" — because they each lead with a different one.
SimplePractice
SimplePractice
Best for: Cash-pay and hybrid practices that prioritize client experience, telehealth, and marketing
SimplePractice is an all-in-one behavioral health EHR built around a best-in-class client portal. It handles scheduling, customizable documentation, built-in telehealth, online booking, secure messaging, card-on-file billing, and its own Monarch client directory. The AI Note Taker add-on records sessions and drafts SOAP, DAP, or BIRP notes, and a large integration marketplace connects third-party AI scribes and tools.
Strengths
- The best client experience in behavioral health. The portal, online booking, intake flow, and telehealth all feel like modern consumer software. For a practice where the client's first impression and ongoing convenience matter — especially cash-pay and hybrid — this is the single biggest reason to choose it. It reduces no-show friction and makes the practice look polished.
- Monarch directory for marketing. SimplePractice bundles its own client-facing directory. Given that an unmanaged referral pipeline is one of the top pains for private practice (when you're full you stop marketing, then openings sit empty), a built-in listing that feeds the top of your funnel is a real, if secondary, advantage. TherapyNotes has nothing equivalent.
- Widest AI and integration ecosystem. Beyond the native AI Note Taker (SOAP, DAP, BIRP), SimplePractice connects to the broadest set of third-party scribes and tools — Mentalyc, Blueprint, Upheal, Supanote, Twofold, and more — so you're not locked into one AI vendor's note style.
- Strong mobile apps. Both a clinician app and a dedicated client app, both well-rated — useful for therapists who chart or check their schedule between sessions.
- Published, plannable pricing. Starter, Essential, and Plus tiers are listed openly, with a 30-day free trial, so you can budget before talking to anyone.
Weaknesses
- Insurance billing is the weaker half. SimplePractice files claims and has improved, but its revenue-cycle depth, batch-claim handling, and ERA workflow are widely considered a step behind TherapyNotes. For an insurance-heavy practice, that gap shows up as more manual billing work.
- Costs climb with add-ons and tiers. The AI Note Taker is +$35/month per clinician on top of your plan, and some features (like the fuller billing and reminder tooling) require Essential or Plus rather than Starter. Price the plan you'll actually run, not the $49 floor.
- No native e-prescribing. Psychiatrists and PMHNPs who need to e-prescribe — especially controlled substances via EPCS — won't get it here natively. That's often a dealbreaker for prescribers.
- Per-clinician pricing adds up for groups. A multi-clinician practice pays the full per-seat rate across the board, which can make it pricier than TherapyNotes at scale.
TherapyNotes
TherapyNotes
Best for: Insurance-based, group, and psychiatric practices that need deep billing and e-prescribing
TherapyNotes is a behavioral health EHR built around insurance billing and reliability. It includes a built-in clearinghouse, electronic claims and ERA posting, batch claims, structured audit-ready note templates, scheduling, included telehealth, a client portal, appointment reminders, and e-prescribing with EPCS for prescribers. The TherapyFuel add-on transcribes sessions and drafts SOAP progress notes. US-based phone support is the best in the category.
Strengths
- Best-in-class insurance billing. This is the decisive reason to choose it. A built-in clearinghouse, electronic claim submission and ERA posting, batch claims, and a to-do workflow that walks you through the revenue cycle make getting paid dramatically less painful than doing it manually. For the majority of private practices that bill insurance — where prior auth and denials already eat 5–10% of revenue — this is where the money is.
- Lower cost, especially for groups. A solo practice starts around $59/month, and each additional clinician is only about $30/month (plus a small per-seat fee for non-clinical staff). A group practice typically lands well under SimplePractice's full per-seat pricing.
- Native e-prescribing with EPCS. For psychiatrists, PMHNPs, and any prescriber, built-in e-prescribing — including controlled substances — is a category-defining advantage SimplePractice simply doesn't match natively.
- Structured, audit-ready documentation. TherapyNotes' built-in note templates (intake, progress note, treatment plan, psych eval) are designed to survive payer audits, with fields that nudge you toward medical-necessity language and outcome measures.
- The best support in the category. US-based phone support with short hold times gets consistently strong reviews — a real differentiator when a claim is stuck and payroll depends on it.
Weaknesses
- Dated, utilitarian interface. It works and it's reliable, but it looks like clinical software, not a consumer app. The client portal is functional rather than delightful, and the learning curve is a bit steeper.
- Thin mobile app. If you chart or manage your schedule from your phone, TherapyNotes' mobile experience is noticeably weaker than SimplePractice's.
- AI notes are SOAP-only. TherapyFuel (~$40/clinician/month) generates SOAP-format progress notes, but not the DAP, BIRP, or GIRP formats many therapists prefer. If note-format flexibility matters, that's a limit.
- No marketing directory and a limited API. There's no Monarch-style listing to feed new clients, and the platform's limited API and lack of bulk-action tools can frustrate growing practices that want deeper integrations.
- Usage-based add-ons. Appointment reminders carry small per-message fees beyond an allotment, and e-prescribing is a paid add-on — so the real monthly bill can run above the headline rate.
Head-to-head
Pricing
This is a genuine split, and it runs opposite to the usual "cheaper tool is worse" assumption.
SimplePractice publishes three per-clinician tiers — Starter around $49/month, Essential around $79/month, and Plus around $99/month — with a 30-day free trial. The AI Note Taker is an extra ~$35/month per clinician, so a solo clinician who wants AI notes on the Starter plan is looking at roughly $84/month. Some billing and reminder capabilities require stepping up to Essential or Plus, so the tier you actually need is usually not the floor.
TherapyNotes starts around $59/month for a solo clinician, with each additional clinician only about $30/month and non-clinical staff seats a few dollars each. TherapyFuel AI is about $40/clinician/month on top. The gotchas here are usage-based: text/voice appointment reminders carry small per-message fees, and e-prescribing is a separate paid add-on. It also tends to run a free trial, though confirm the current length.
The practical takeaway: for a solo cash-pay therapist who wants AI notes and a great client portal, the two land close once you add SimplePractice's AI Note Taker. For a group practice, TherapyNotes is usually meaningfully cheaper because of the ~$30 per-additional-clinician structure versus full per-seat pricing. Spec the exact footprint you'll run — number of clinicians, AI notes yes/no, reminders volume, e-prescribing yes/no — and get the total monthly cost in writing for both before deciding. (Again: these figures were last checked in May 2026; confirm current pricing directly.)
AI / Automation features
Both now ship a native AI scribe, and both let you bring your own. The difference is breadth.
SimplePractice's AI Note Taker records in-person or telehealth sessions and drafts notes in SOAP, DAP, or BIRP, plus pre-appointment summaries that pull from recent notes and treatment plans — all inside the EHR, with no copy-paste. TherapyNotes' TherapyFuel transcribes sessions and drafts SOAP-format progress notes, plus a Client History Summary for intakes; notably, TherapyNotes gives all clinicians in a practice free access to Generate Contact Notes and history summaries if at least one clinician subscribes.
Where SimplePractice pulls ahead is the third-party ecosystem: it connects to a wider range of specialized scribes (Mentalyc, Blueprint, Upheal, Supanote, Twofold), so you can choose the one whose note voice and format you like best. If AI documentation quality or format flexibility is your priority, read our full breakdown of therapy-specific scribes in the mental health practice AI guide — several of those tools integrate with both EHRs and may matter more than the native add-on either platform ships.
Integrations
Both integrate with the major therapy AI scribes and with measurement-based care tools (both have built-in PHQ-9/GAD-7, and both connect to Blueprint for deeper outcome tracking). SimplePractice has the broader integration marketplace and the Monarch directory. TherapyNotes has a narrower integration surface and a limited API, which is one of the more common complaints from growing group practices that want to wire the EHR into other systems. If a rich third-party stack is part of your plan, SimplePractice is the safer bet; if you mainly need the EHR to bill cleanly on its own, TherapyNotes' tighter surface is fine.
Customer support & onboarding
TherapyNotes wins support decisively — US-based phone support with short waits is a repeated highlight in reviews, and it matters most exactly when something is on fire (a denied batch of claims, a portal outage before a full day of sessions). SimplePractice leans on email, chat, and an extensive help center, with more limited phone access; fine for most questions, frustrating in an emergency. Onboarding for both is a matter of days to a couple of weeks depending on whether you're migrating historical data and how many payers you bill — budget more time on TherapyNotes if you're setting up electronic claims across several payers, and more time on SimplePractice if you're building out the client portal, booking, and Monarch profile.
Where SimplePractice wins
- You're cash-pay or hybrid and client experience is your edge. If clients find you, book, pay, and attend telehealth without friction — and the practice looks polished doing it — you fill and keep a caseload more easily. SimplePractice's portal, booking, and mobile apps are the best in behavioral health, and for a private-pay practice that's worth more than billing depth you'll rarely use.
- Marketing and a full caseload are the number you're losing on. The bundled Monarch directory feeds new-client inquiries. For a practice that goes quiet on marketing whenever it's full and then scrambles when openings appear, a built-in listing at the top of the funnel is a real advantage TherapyNotes can't match.
- You want the widest AI and integration options. Native AI notes in SOAP, DAP, and BIRP, plus the broadest third-party scribe and app marketplace, mean you're not locked into one note style or one vendor's roadmap.
- You live on your phone. Strong clinician and client mobile apps make SimplePractice the better fit if you check your schedule or chart between sessions on a phone.
Where TherapyNotes wins
- You bill insurance — which is most of private practice. This is the decisive scenario. A built-in clearinghouse, electronic claims, ERA posting, batch claims, and a revenue-cycle to-do workflow make getting paid far less painful than SimplePractice's billing. Since insurance billing and denials are among the biggest operational drains in a mental health practice, the tool that does this best usually wins the whole decision.
- You run a group practice and watch per-seat cost. At roughly $30 per additional clinician versus full per-seat pricing, TherapyNotes is typically the cheaper platform as you add clinicians — often by a wide margin at 4+ seats.
- You prescribe. Native e-prescribing with EPCS for controlled substances is a category-defining advantage for psychiatrists and PMHNPs. SimplePractice has no native equivalent.
- You want audit-proof documentation and real support. Structured, medical-necessity-oriented note templates plus US phone support are exactly what you want when a payer requests a chart or a claim gets stuck.
Where they're equivalent
Don't let a salesperson invent differences here. For the everyday core of running a practice, these platforms are close enough that it won't decide your choice:
- Scheduling and recurring appointments — both handle weekly/biweekly recurring sessions, cancellations, and calendar management well.
- Built-in telehealth — both include HIPAA-aware video; SimplePractice's is a bit more polished, but both work reliably for standard sessions.
- Appointment reminders — both send SMS/email reminders that cut no-shows (industry data shows automated reminders reduce no-shows up to ~29%); TherapyNotes meters some reminders with small per-message fees, so check volume.
- Secure client messaging and a portal — both offer HIPAA-secure messaging and a client portal; SimplePractice's is slicker, TherapyNotes' is functional.
- Built-in outcome measures — both include PHQ-9 and GAD-7 administration and scoring, and both integrate with Blueprint for deeper measurement-based care.
- Custom and standard note formats for typed notes — both support structured progress notes, intakes, and treatment plans (the AI-format gap is only on their respective AI scribes).
- HIPAA posture and BAA — both are used across behavioral health and both will sign a BAA; get it in hand before sending a single client message either way.
Migration cost & lock-in
The honest friction, because this is where buyers get surprised.
Choosing SimplePractice means investing time in the client-facing setup — building out the portal, online booking rules, intake forms, telehealth, and your Monarch profile — plus configuring documentation templates and connecting any third-party AI scribe. The lock-in is less about data and more about the client experience you've built and the per-clinician subscription you'll keep paying as you grow.
Choosing TherapyNotes means investing time in billing setup — enrolling each payer for electronic claims and ERA, configuring the clearinghouse, and setting up e-prescribing if you prescribe. That electronic-claims plumbing is the most time-consuming part of onboarding, and it's also what makes leaving later feel heavier: you'll re-enroll payers wherever you go next.
Switching between the two later: the good news is your clinical record is exportable — both let you export client data, and you own your records under the 21st Century Cures Act. What doesn't travel cleanly are note templates, saved automations, reminder and billing configurations, payer enrollments, and portal/booking setup, all of which you'll rebuild on the new platform. Historical notes usually migrate as PDFs or exports rather than fully structured, editable records, so plan for a cutover period where you keep read-only access to the old system. Whichever way you go, two rules hold: one named person should own the EHR (usually the practice owner or office manager — tools that are "everyone's job" quietly stop getting claims out the door), and pull a 90-day baseline first (no-show rate, days-in-AR, claim denial rate, caseload fill) so you can actually prove the switch paid off at renewal. For how the EHR fits alongside AI scribes, intake automation, and billing tools in the broader stack, see our full mental health practice AI guide.
Our pick
For most private practices in 2026 — the solo and small-group clinicians who bill at least some insurance — TherapyNotes is the better default. The reason isn't that it out-designs SimplePractice (it doesn't; SimplePractice is prettier and easier to love). It's that TherapyNotes is strongest at the thing that actually bleeds money in a mental health practice: insurance billing. It gets claims out cleanly, posts remittances, works denials through a to-do workflow, costs less per clinician — especially for groups — and backs it with the best phone support in the category and native e-prescribing for practices that prescribe. When the tie-breaker is "which problem is costing me money," for an insurance practice the answer is billing, and TherapyNotes wins it.
We'd choose SimplePractice instead in a clear set of cases: you're cash-pay or hybrid and client experience is your competitive edge; marketing and a full caseload are your bottleneck and you want the Monarch directory feeding inquiries; you want the widest AI and integration ecosystem; or you simply value a modern, mobile-friendly interface your clients and staff will actually enjoy using. For those practices, SimplePractice's polish is worth more than billing depth they'll rarely lean on.
And neither is right if what you really want is an AI-native, all-in-one platform at a lower monthly cost — in that case look at Upheal or Blueprint in our mental health AI tools guide, which can replace or ride alongside a traditional EHR at a different price point.
The tie-breaker, if both look workable: which number are you losing on right now? Losing time and revenue to insurance billing, denials, and prescribing workflow → TherapyNotes. Losing clients to a clunky intake, an empty marketing pipeline, or a dated portal → SimplePractice. Run both free trials against your own practice — load a week of real sessions and a few real claims — before you commit to a year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is SimplePractice or TherapyNotes better for therapists?
It depends on how you get paid. For insurance-based practices — most of private practice — TherapyNotes is better: it has deeper insurance billing (built-in clearinghouse, electronic claims, ERA posting, batch claims), costs less per clinician, offers native e-prescribing, and has the best phone support in the category. For cash-pay or hybrid practices that prioritize client experience and marketing, SimplePractice is better thanks to its best-in-class client portal, telehealth, mobile apps, and built-in Monarch directory. Both handle scheduling, notes, telehealth, and PHQ-9/GAD-7, so the deciding factor is billing depth versus client-facing polish.
How much do SimplePractice and TherapyNotes cost?
SimplePractice publishes per-clinician tiers — around $49/month (Starter), $79/month (Essential), and $99/month (Plus) — plus about $35/month per clinician for the AI Note Taker add-on, with a 30-day free trial. TherapyNotes starts around $59/month for a solo clinician, with each additional clinician only about $30/month and TherapyFuel AI about $40/clinician/month; reminders and e-prescribing are usage-based or add-on costs. For groups, TherapyNotes is usually cheaper. These figures were last verified in May 2026, so confirm current pricing on each vendor's page before deciding.
Which one is better for insurance billing?
TherapyNotes. It's built around the revenue cycle, with a built-in clearinghouse, electronic claim submission, electronic remittance (ERA) posting, batch claims, and a to-do workflow that walks you through getting paid. SimplePractice files claims and has improved, but its billing depth, batch handling, and ERA workflow are generally considered a step behind. If a large share of your revenue comes through insurance, TherapyNotes' billing advantage usually outweighs SimplePractice's nicer interface.
Does SimplePractice or TherapyNotes support e-prescribing for psychiatry?
TherapyNotes offers native e-prescribing, including EPCS for controlled substances, which makes it the clear choice for psychiatrists and PMHNPs. SimplePractice does not offer native e-prescribing. If you prescribe medication, that single difference usually decides it in TherapyNotes' favor (or pushes prescribers toward a psychiatry-focused EHR entirely).
Can I switch from SimplePractice to TherapyNotes later?
Yes, but plan for friction. You own and can export your clinical records under the 21st Century Cures Act, so your data travels with you — but usually as PDFs or exports rather than fully structured, editable notes. What you'll rebuild are note templates, reminder and billing configurations, payer enrollments for electronic claims, and your portal and booking setup. Keep read-only access to the old system during the cutover, time the switch to your renewal date, and pull a 90-day baseline of no-show rate, days-in-AR, and denial rate first so you can prove the move was worth it.
Which has better AI note-taking?
They're close, with an edge to SimplePractice on flexibility. SimplePractice's AI Note Taker ($35/month per clinician) drafts SOAP, DAP, and BIRP notes inside the EHR, and the platform connects to a wider set of third-party scribes (Mentalyc, Blueprint, Upheal, Supanote, Twofold). TherapyNotes' TherapyFuel ($40/clinician/month) generates SOAP-format notes only, though it shares free contact-note and history-summary features across the practice. If note-format flexibility or picking a best-in-class standalone scribe matters most, compare the dedicated therapy AI tools in our mental health practice guide — several integrate with both EHRs.